What Is the Good Moral Character Naturalization Requirement?
- By Fileright
- Last Updated:
When applying for U.S. citizenship, one of the most important things the government checks is whether you have good moral character. This means you’ve followed the law, behaved responsibly, and generally lived as a good member of your community. It’s not just about staying out of serious legal trouble—it also includes smaller actions that show honesty, respect, and integrity.
The good moral character naturalization rule helps immigration officers decide if you’re ready to become a U.S. citizen. They look closely at your background, especially during the years leading up to your application. If you have a complicated history, it may be smart to speak with an immigration attorney before filing to make sure you’re presenting the strongest case possible.
Why Good Moral Character Matters for Naturalization
The United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) uses the good moral character naturalization standard to protect the values of citizenship. U.S. citizens are expected to follow the law and contribute positively to society. This means that applicants must meet more than just the basic requirements—they must also prove they are trustworthy and respectful of the country’s laws and values.
Even something as simple as forgetting to pay taxes or failing to report an address change can cause questions about your character. While these actions may not seem like major crimes, they can reflect negatively on your overall case if not explained properly. That’s why every detail matters when you apply for naturalization. The government wants to ensure that new citizens will be responsible participants in civic life.
Crimes That Permanently Prevent You from Showing Good Moral Character
Some crimes are so serious that if you’re convicted of them, you’ll be permanently barred from becoming a U.S. citizen. These include murder and a category of crimes called “aggravated felonies.” Examples include drug trafficking, sexual abuse of a minor, violent assault, or major fraud. Even if these crimes occurred many years ago, they will still block you from qualifying for citizenship.
The law treats these crimes as signs of a deep lack of moral character. Even if you’ve completed your sentence and rebuilt your life, USCIS does not allow exceptions for these types of offenses. Once they appear on your record, they usually end the path to naturalization permanently. This is true even if you meet all other naturalization requirements, such as residency, English proficiency, and civic knowledge.
What Are Crimes of Moral Turpitude?
Crimes of moral turpitude (CMTs) are a broader category of offenses that reflect bad intentions, dishonesty, or harmful behavior. They don’t have to be violent crimes. For example, stealing, lying to authorities, or abusing someone emotionally or physically may count as CMTs. The courts decide what qualifies based on the circumstances and the law in your state.
One reason CMTs are hard to define is that there isn’t a single law listing all of them. Instead, immigration officials decide based on previous court cases and state laws. This means someone might not realize that an old crime on their record could hurt their application. That’s why it’s essential to review your record carefully before filing for naturalization.
Examples of Crimes of Moral Turpitude (CMTs)
USCIS and immigration courts have identified many offenses as crimes of moral turpitude. Here are some examples that have been found to disqualify people from proving good moral character for naturalization:
- Aggravated assault
- Animal cruelty or fighting
- Child abuse or neglect
- Fraud, perjury, identity theft, or sexual assault
- Armed robbery or burglary
- Domestic violence or spousal abuse
- Voluntary manslaughter
- Kidnapping
- Tax evasion or false tax filings
- Making false statements on immigration forms
Some of these may also be aggravated felonies, which makes them even more serious. If you’ve been accused or convicted of one of these crimes, talk to an immigration lawyer before applying. They may help you seek waivers, explain your case, or postpone your application until you’re eligible.
Can Time Heal Past Offenses?
Yes, depending on the type of offense and how long ago it happened. For many offenses, if enough time has passed and you haven’t committed any other crimes, you may still qualify. This is why USCIS looks at the five years before your naturalization application—or three years if you’re married to a U.S. citizen.
If your past offense happened more than five years ago and doesn’t fall into the category of aggravated felonies or permanent bars, it may not block you. However, USCIS could still look further into your past if something raises concerns during the review process. Having a clean recent history, a stable lifestyle, and proof of community involvement can help demonstrate rehabilitation.
Conditional Bars to Good Moral Character
Conditional bars are offenses that disqualify you from showing good moral character—but only if they happened during the review period. These bars don’t automatically deny you citizenship forever, but they will delay your eligibility. These include many common infractions or lifestyle issues that USCIS takes seriously.
Common conditional bars include:
- Two or more DUI convictions
- Illegal drug possession (other than marijuana under 30 grams)
- Lying on an immigration application
- Failing to pay taxes or file tax returns
- Not paying child support
- Being married to multiple people at the same time
- Gambling or other illegal betting offenses
Even if an issue occurred during the review period, you can improve your chances by being honest and showing that you’ve made positive life changes. Letters of support from community leaders or evidence of rehabilitation can help.
How USCIS Investigates Good Moral Character
To evaluate good moral character for naturalization, USCIS reviews several types of documents and records. This includes your immigration file, background checks through the FBI, and local court records. They also consider your behavior during your time as a green card holder—not just your criminal record.
USCIS may request or review:
- Police clearance certificates
- Certified court dispositions
- Tax records and payment confirmations
- Employment history
- Proof of community involvement
- Statements from character witnesses
USCIS officers are also trained to assess credibility. If your application includes incomplete or suspicious information, it could trigger a more detailed investigation. Being honest and thorough is always the best approach.
How Intent Affects Good Moral Character
In some cases, your intent behind a past action can significantly influence whether USCIS considers it a moral failing. For instance, failing to file taxes might be seen differently if you can prove it was due to a lack of understanding rather than trying to cheat or defraud the government.
Also, if you committed a crime under duress or extreme emotional circumstances, this may be taken into account. Officers review not just what you did, but why you did it, especially if your actions show growth or remorse afterward. A personal written statement can be a helpful part of your application in these situations.
Do Juvenile Offenses Count Against You?
Generally, juvenile offenses (crimes committed before age 18) do not automatically disqualify you from meeting the good moral character naturalization requirement. However, serious crimes committed as a minor—especially those treated as adult offenses in court—may still impact your case.
USCIS may review your full background if there’s a pattern of concerning behavior. For example, if you had multiple juvenile arrests and continued to break the law as an adult, that could raise red flags. On the other hand, if your youthful offenses were followed by years of good behavior, stable employment, and education, that works in your favor.
Does Receiving Public Benefits Affect Good Moral Character?
Receiving public benefits like food stamps, Medicaid, or housing assistance typically does not impact your good moral character unless obtained fraudulently. For example, if someone lies on an application to receive benefits they’re not eligible for, that could count as fraud and reflect poorly on their moral character.
Always be truthful when applying for benefits. If you’ve received government aid legally and honestly, it should not harm your citizenship application. If you’re unsure about your benefit history, it’s a good idea to review those records or consult with an immigration attorney before filing for naturalization.
How to Strengthen Your Naturalization Case
Even if your record isn’t perfect, there are steps you can take to strengthen your case. Providing verifiable documentation that proves you’ve positively changed your life, learned from your mistakes and bad decisions, and actively contribute to your community can improve your chances.
Here are a few different ways to support your naturalization application:
- Include letters of recommendation from teachers, clergy, close friends, or employers
- Proof of your volunteer time with local nonprofits or charities
- Take responsibility for past mistakes in a personal statement
- Stay current with all tax and legal obligations
- Complete any court-ordered community service or education programs
- Gather proof of steady employment or education history
These efforts show you’re committed to living as a responsible, law-abiding member of American society.
Let FileRight Help You Apply With Confidence
If you’re not sure whether you meet the good moral character naturalization requirement, FileRight can help simplify the process. Our application platform walks you through each step of Form N-400, helping you avoid mistakes and delays.
We also offer a lawyer review service to make sure your application is ready for USCIS. If we make an error that causes your application to be rejected, we’ll refund your fees. Whether you’re just getting started or already gathering documents, we can help you move forward with confidence.
Take our free naturalization eligibility quiz today and start your journey toward U.S. citizenship the smart way.
